Is It Worth Using a Builder’s Preferred Lender?

Is it worth using a builder’s preferred lender? It can be, when the incentive is worth more than any extra cost in the loan. The only way to tell is to compare Loan Estimates for the same loan from the builder’s lender and at least one other lender. A Loan Estimate is the standard form a lender sends after you apply, showing the loan’s terms and estimated costs.

Federal mortgage rules separate two things: being required to use a provider, and being offered a package or discount, which the rule says has to be optional. And the money at stake is real, because a credit at closing can be outweighed by higher costs inside the loan.

Four things settle it: what the federal rule says, what the incentive is worth, how the two offers compare, and what to ask before you sign.

Can a Builder Make You Use Its Lender?

Start with Regulation X’s definition of required use. Under the federal rule, a required use is when you have to use a particular provider to get access to something else, such as the home, and pay for it. The rule says a package or a discount for using more than one settlement service isn’t a required use.

Regulation X is the federal rule that carries out RESPA, the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. It defines required use as a situation in which “a person must use a particular provider of a settlement service in order to have access to some distinct service or property”. A settlement service is a service tied to closing on a home, and the rule’s own list of them starts with “Origination of a federally related mortgage loan”. In plain terms, making the mortgage counts.

The rule also carves out deals. Offering a package of settlement services, or a discount or rebate for buying more than one of them, “does not constitute a required use” under Regulation X. The rule attaches a condition to that: “Any package or discount must be optional to the purchaser.”

Whether a particular builder’s offer or contract fits that definition is a question for a real estate attorney, and the time to ask is before you sign. The practical step doesn’t change either way. Ask the builder, in writing, whether the incentive is optional, and what the price and the credits look like if you finance elsewhere.

What Is the Builder’s Incentive Really Worth?

An incentive is whatever the builder offers for using that lender, such as a credit toward closing costs or upgrades. Its value is the incentive minus anything extra you’d pay inside the loan to get it. You can’t see that second number without a Loan Estimate from another lender for the same loan.

Regulation X sets a standard for a discount: “The discount must be a true discount below the prices that are otherwise generally available”, and it “must not be made up by higher costs elsewhere in the settlement process”. Comparing two Loan Estimates shows whether higher loan costs offset the incentive for your own file. Start with the offer itself, in writing:

  • The dollar amount of the incentive.
  • What it pays for, such as closing costs or upgrades.
  • Every condition attached to it, including which lender and any deadline.
  • What changes if you use another lender instead.

The builder is the seller. So a closing-cost credit from the builder is a seller credit. Before you count on one, read how much a seller can pay toward your closing costs.

How Do You Compare the Builder’s Lender With Another Lender?

Request a Loan Estimate from the builder’s lender and from at least one other lender, then put them side by side for the same loan. That’s the method the CFPB’s guide to requesting multiple Loan Estimates describes. The CFPB is the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

The CFPB’s next instruction is to “Ask each lender for the same kind of loan with the same features”, so the two forms line up. Once you’ve submitted the request, the CFPB says “each lender is required to send you a Loan Estimate within three business days”.

Timing matters, and the CFPB is direct about it: “You do not need a signed purchase agreement to get a Loan Estimate.” So you can compare lenders before you sign the builder’s contract, not after.

Shopping two lenders doesn’t have to mean two marks on your credit. The CFPB says, “Within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded on your credit report as a single inquiry.” Compare more than one lender inside that window and the checks count as one inquiry.

Check whether each rate is locked. The CFPB says some lenders lock your rate as part of issuing the Loan Estimate, and some don’t. Its warning is plain: “If your rate is not locked, it can change at any time.”

Then compare the two forms item by item. For the fees, the credits, the rate and the cash you’d bring to closing, see how to compare Loan Estimates line by line.

When Does the Builder’s Lender Make Sense?

When its Loan Estimate for the same loan holds up against the other offer, and the incentive is money you’d give up by financing elsewhere, the builder’s lender can be the better deal. When the loan costs more than the incentive is worth, it isn’t. The two estimates settle it.

Say the builder offers a $5,000 credit toward closing costs. You request a Loan Estimate from each lender for the same loan, and the builder’s lender’s estimate shows $3,000 more in lender fees than the other offer. On closing costs, the incentive is worth about $2,000 to you.

Then compare the interest rate and the monthly payment on both estimates, because a higher rate means a higher payment for as long as that rate applies, and that can outweigh a one-time credit. Work it through with the numbers on your own two forms.

The arithmetic runs the other way too. If the builder’s lender’s estimate matches the other offer, the incentive is money in your favor.

What Should You Ask Before You Sign the Builder’s Contract?

Ask before you sign. The contract is where the incentive, any lender terms and the deadlines get set. A Loan Estimate from each lender can be in hand first, so take your questions to the builder while the contract is still unsigned.

Fellowship gives every buyer the same advice at the lender-choice step. In the team’s words: “Fellowship Home Loans recommends exploring a few options to discern the most favorable rates and terms tailored to your loan requirements.”

  • Is the incentive optional, and what’s the price and the credit if I use another lender?
  • What does the incentive pay for, exactly?
  • Does the contract name a lender, or ask me to apply with one?
  • What deadlines does the contract set for financing?
  • Can I get the preferred lender’s Loan Estimate before I commit?

Contract questions go to a real estate attorney. Loan questions go to a loan officer. Splitting them that way puts each answer with the person who can give it.

To see each step from application to closing, read how the Fellowship mortgage process works.

For the loan types Fellowship offers buyers, visit Fellowship’s home purchase loan page.

Frequently Asked Questions About Builder’s Preferred Lenders

Can a builder require you to use its lender?

Regulation X defines required use, and it says a package or a discount for buying more than one settlement service has to be optional to the purchaser. Whether a specific offer or contract fits that definition is a question for a real estate attorney. Ask the builder in writing.

Do you need a signed contract to get a Loan Estimate?

No. The CFPB says a signed purchase agreement isn’t needed to get a Loan Estimate. That means you can request one from the builder’s lender and one from another lender, then compare the two before you sign anything with the builder.

Will getting more than one Loan Estimate hurt my credit?

The CFPB says that within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded on your credit report as a single inquiry. So comparing the builder’s lender with another lender inside that window counts as one inquiry rather than two.

Is a Loan Estimate an approval?

No. The CFPB says that when you receive a Loan Estimate, the lender hasn’t yet approved or denied your loan. The form shows the terms and estimated costs a lender is quoting, which is what makes two of them comparable. Approval is a separate decision.

What should I compare between the two Loan Estimates?

Start with the same kind of loan and the same features from each lender. Then check whether each rate is locked, the fees and credits on each form, the interest rate and the monthly payment, and the cash you’d bring to closing. Compare them side by side.

Is the builder’s lender ever the better choice?

Yes. When its Loan Estimate for the same loan holds up against the other offer, and the incentive is money you’d give up by financing elsewhere, it can be the better deal. The comparison is what tells you, file by file.

Compare Before You Commit

An incentive is worth what’s left after the loan’s costs. So get the offer in writing, request a Loan Estimate from each lender for the same loan, and decide with both forms in front of you. Make the comparison before the contract deadline, not after it.

  • Get the incentive and its conditions in writing.
  • Ask whether it’s optional, and what changes if you use another lender.
  • Request Loan Estimates for the same loan from the builder’s lender and from another lender.
  • Compare the fees, the credits, the rate and the monthly payment before the contract deadline.

For a second set of numbers to set beside the builder’s offer, ask a Fellowship loan officer for a Loan Estimate to compare.

Picture of By Brian Schiele
By Brian Schiele

Brian Schiele co-founded Fellowship Home Loans with Mike Rakeman, and the two have worked in the mortgage business for more than 15 years. Brian lays out every option in plain terms, so each borrower knows what a loan means for their budget before they sign. He and Mike built the company on honesty and service, and they make a point of giving back to the community, including a mortgage-payment sweepstakes for local families.

Ready to learn explore your home purchase or refinancing options? Get started today!

Get Your FREE RATE QUOTE